Mad Max Is Back: How Scherzer’s Return Could Fuel a Blue Jays Playoff Push

When the Toronto Blue Jays signed Max Scherzer, they didn’t just add a three-time Cy Young winner—they secured one of baseball’s fiercest competitors, a presence so electric it sparks energy through the entire clubhouse. After months on the injured list, Scherzer finally returned to the mound, and what fans witnessed wasn't just a rehab milestone—it was a potential turning point in Toronto’s 2025 season.

For the full podcast episode, please go to youtube.com/@birdwatchinggc and subscribe for future updates. Audio can be found on any site you receive your podcast pleasures from as well.

Five Innings, Full Intensity

Scherzer’s long-awaited return came against the very good Cleveland Guardians team and in their home ballpark yesterday. While the box score will show a modest line—5 IP, 3 ER, 4 K, 3 BB, 6 H—the impact stretched far beyond the numbers. From the first pitch, Scherzer brought his trademark ferocity, stalking the mound with the kind of intensity that reminded fans why he’s earned the moniker “Mad Max.”

He punched out the side in the first inning, flashing vintage velocity and sharp command. His fastball consistently touched the mid-90s, and he mixed in his slider and changeup with confidence while moving the ball up-down, in and out. More importantly, he gave the Jays something they desperately needed, stability in a rotation spot that has been in flux!

For a rotation that’s leaned heavily on Bassitt, Berrios, and Gausman, Scherzer's return offers relief and reassurance.

Plugging the Rotation Leak

Before this start, the Jays had cycled through bullpen games and emergency call-ups. With Bowden Francis faltering in his turn of late prior to heading to the IL this team was really looking for some length out of two spots in their pitching rotation. The team has been working with a patchwork of "Quadruple-A" players and even signed Spencer Turnbull (also recently designated for assignment) in attempts to get something to gel. Scherzer being back is a stabilizer—someone capable of saving the bullpen, eating innings, and shutting down elite lineups when it matters most. Scherzer in addition to the emergence of Eric Lauer could spell success!

That presence was felt in more ways than one. His fiery response to questionable calls, his command of pitch tempo, and even the moment he challenged an umpire’s decision on a disengagement violation—it was all classic Max. That passion bleeds into a clubhouse, especially during a postseason chase.

The Ripple Effect: Playoff Mentality Incoming

With Scherzer back, the Blue Jays don't just gain a pitcher, they gain a tone-setter. He doesn’t tolerate complacency. He expects greatness. And that edge was something the Jays lacked last season down the stretch.

Consider this: Scherzer is one of the few active pitchers with 20+ career postseason starts. As the playoff race tightens and the AL East continues its unpredictable free fall—with the Yankees slipping at the moment and the Orioles falling off, Toronto has a secret weapon in Scherzer’s experience.

If he can stay healthy and ramp up to 5-7 innings per start consistently by late July, this rotation transforms from solid to formidable. Gausman, Bassitt, Berrios, Scherzer—paired with a recharged bullpen, an emerging offense, and some potential splashes at the MLB Trade Deadline, suddenly gives Toronto a legitimate blueprint for running into October.

Final Thoughts: This Is Why They Got Him

Max Scherzer didn’t need to be perfect in his return. He just needed to be back. Judging by last night’s performance, he’s well on his way. If he continues this trajectory, don’t be surprised if we look back at that hot night in Cleveland as the moment the Jays’ season turned it up a notch. Mad Max does not have to be the Cy Young award level he once was but if he can hold teams to 3-4 runs like he did last night in Cleveland, this team has a heck of an asset and a veteran that knows how to win!